• Home
  • About
  • Contact
    • Work With Me
  • My Shop
  • Start Here

A Mother Far from Home

  • Discipline
    • Toys And Play
    • Big Family
    • Family Culture
    • Diapers & Potty Training
    • Irish Twins
    • Teething
  • Emotions
  • Faith
    • Christian Holidays
    • Church Related
    • Spiritual Principles
  • Home
    • Cleaning & Chores
    • Meal Time & Eating
    • Organizing, Tidying & Decluttering
    • Emergency Preparedness For Families
  • Motherhood
    • Mental & Emotional Wholeness
    • Mother’s Helper
    • Type A Wife and Mom
    • Books to Read
    • Pregnancy
  • Routine
    • Baby Schedules & Routines
    • Toddler Routines & Schedules
    • Mom Schedules & Routines
    • School Routines
  • Sleeping
    • Sleep Troubleshooting
    • Napping Tips
    • Basic Sleep Tips
Home » Practical Parenting Tips » How to praise without over using “good girl” or “good boy”

How to praise without over using “good girl” or “good boy”

Updated June 11, 2020

163shares

Want simple chaos-erasing family routines? Who doesn't? Check out our Family Routines Reboot!

Want simple chaos-erasing family routines? Who doesn't? Check out our Family Routines Reboot!

girl eating

I may seem like I run a tight ship (and I do), but I am also nauseatingly affectionate. I hug and kiss and cuddle and make up ridiculous nicknames for my children. They may grow up and think I could have been better at this or that, but they will never be able to say they didn’t know I loved them. Still, after all the gushing, I want to get into some reasons why not to say good girl or good boy in place of specific praise.

Because of this compulsion, things often come out of my mouth before I’ve thought about it. This is okay on the odd occasion, but how and why we praise are kids is very important. They need to know they are cherished, and that their efforts matter. It’s also equally important we don’t lavish praise on them for things out of their control as this leads to insecurity. This isn’t something we need to stress over on a daily basis, but something we should establish on our hearts as we go through this journey of parenthood.

Ultimately, we want our children to know they are pleasing to us, regardless of their behavior in the moment. There will be many moments when they are, in fact, very badly behaved, but that doesn’t change their status in our home or their location in our hearts.

1.  When to use good girl/good boy. 

It’s best to use these terms when communicating love. Not love because of an action or choice, simply love. For example, if you are reading a book, hugging, or just spending quality time together it’s perfectly reasonable to say, “You’re a good girl, honey, I love you so much.” This is a validating phrase and communities your feelings towards your child.

2.  When not to use good girl/good boy. 

If you are using these terms to communicate praise for a certain action, it’s probably best to just praise specifically their action. For example, if your son comes home with a good grade on a test, it’s better to say, “Great job on studying and acing your exam” instead of “good boy, well done.”

If you’ve asked them to do something repeatedly, or threatened, and they finally comply, that’s not the time to say, “good girl” as though simply doing what you say makes them ‘good.’ You also want to avoid calling one child good in front of another child in a way that makes the other child feel shamed. If one child did what you asked and the other didn’t, a simple “Thanks for doing what I asked, son, I appreciate that” is more effective than “thanks, you’re such a good boy” as though your other child is not.

3.  One thing you can never over praise. 

Nurture Shock is very interesting book and it has an entire chapter on the importance of praising effort, not intelligence. Children are born with a certain level of intelligence that is relatively unchangeable. Of course we can help them reach their IQ potential, but they will not become a genius by studying harder. Effort, on the other hand, is entirely in the control of the child. Whether they try hard, work hard, and persevere is based on their own self-motivation and willpower.

Instead of, “Great job making an A+, you’re so smart” you might say, “I’m happy to see the effort you put into studying, it definitely paid off.” As opposed to, “You’re a natural dancer, you don’t even have to try to look stunning,” you’d do better to say, “It’s great that you really give it your all in the studio, that’s the key to success.”

According to Nurture Shock, those regularly praised for effort try harder and overcome adversity. Those praised for factors outside their control (ie. beauty, brains, athletic ability) are more insecure in their talents because they see any perceived failure as a sign they are not, in fact, what they’ve been said to be.

4.  Find and use key phrases. 

Since I gush and swoon over my babies, I’ve thought of a few key phrases I can say instead of “good girl” or “good boy.” Now I replace those with simple phrases such as the following, that can adapted for many situations. The goal is to be specific in why we are praising, and to praise their actions, not their being.

Good effort. 

{X} was very helpful. 

Thanks for listening and doing what I asked. 

Atta boy. 

I appreciate how you {x}

That’s the way. 

In all honesty, as long as you are regularly praising your children and showing them you love them and are proud of who they are becoming… they’ll be fine. This isn’t about giving us something else to do or not do. Rather, I hope we can begin to think about praise in a new way. It may all sound a little pedantic, but just know that your heart behind the matter is what counts. Children will pick up on the nuances of your communication so it’s best to be aware, but nothing to stress over too heavily.

We can learn to separate our communication where we aim to say “I love you” and the communication where we aim to say “You did that well.”

Want to learn your parenting style?

Each of us have our own personality, temperament, and giftings. And, the truth is, we parent best when we work with these instead of against them. Take this assessment so you can work to your strengths, and be the mom you want to be for yourself and your children.

Rachel

New to this community? Start here, friend.

163shares

Filed Under: Practical Parenting Tips6

« Parenting shifts in the past century
What I learned when my stroller had a flat in D.C. »

Recommended For You From Our Shop

Family Culture Planning Pack

Strong Families Don't Happen By Accident

Strong and happy families have carefully crafted Family Cultures.

They don't let guilt drive them, rather they spend their time and energy digging deep into a few key family areas that pay off in spades.

Families don't need to do more and more things, they just need to focus their attention on a few key areas that make for strong families, then repeat those over and over.

Click to Learn More

I'm Rachel, mother of 5 young kids living in the Florida panhandle with my Australian husband. I write about family culture, family rhythms and routines, and boundaries in motherhood and life. You can see snippets of my daily life here and visit my shop for baby sleep, organizing, and routine help.

“Inside my brain”

Geeezzz, it was like you were inside my brain today!  (and most days recently)  I needed this badly.

Thank you!!!
Andrea P.

“Nothing was working…”

I just wanted to say thank you for your easy peasy routine for 2 year olds! I day-weaned my 2 year old a month ago and have been trying everything to get him to go down for a nap without the nursing. Nothing was working and I was starting to think he would never have a nap again.

Anyways I started following your routine and we just sat in bed and had what I told him was “quiet time.” We sat and read and made a fort and had warm milk. Then today I told him it was quiet time again and he tried to escape the bed a couple times, but in the end he snuggled up after the warm bottle and fell asleep for 3 hours! I was almost in tears I was so excited! So thank you!

Meghan

“Thanks for your bundle!”

Thanks for for doing this Everyday Mom Super Bundle sale. I’m four months into my parenthood journey with a sweet and spirited boy.

I was feeling overwhelmed and frustrated just yesterday, thinking if only I had the right resources and “trail guides” I could figure this all out. Your sale is serendipitous. I can’t wait to dig into my download materials and start learning from your tips.

Thanks for sharing your knowledge!

Lauren N.

“It’s a breath of fresh air”

I just wanted to let you know that your blog and emails have been a tremendous help to me. Your practical, honest, and humble writing is a breath of fresh air!

With help and encouragement drawn from your writing, I have made some incredible changes in the order (and sanity) of our home, in just the past few weeks. My kids are doing chores daily, and I also have clearer expectations of myself.

My husband is in awe!

Which helps reinforce what you said- the problem wasn’t me; it was my systems. Our home is in much better order, and so is my mind. So, thank you!!!! You have made a difference for me and my family.

Ann S.

“We are slowly getting back to normal…”

I stumbled upon your blog one morning after praying night after night for God to fix my home! I had just had a baby this May 1st and also have a 2 and 4 year old and my home broke out in complete chaos!

Even my marriage seemed like it was on the brink of extinction and this had happened in 2 weeks! I read numerous amounts of your entries and applied them to my home life and I am happy to say we are slowly getting back to normal. Thank you Rachel! 

Madison S.

“You’ve been a life saver!”

I’m a first time mom to a 15 day old baby girl. I had no idea what I was doing and couldn’t get her to sleep in her crib until I found your blog.

You’ve been a life saver!

Candace R.

“Within a week or two our little girl changed!”

I tumbled into post partum depression/anxiety and didn’t know what to do anymore. I was a mess, baby girl was a mess and I don’t even know how my husband was dealing with it all… 

I googled everything I could think about but there was never really something that felt right, that felt genuine instead of just telling do’s and don’ts. 

And then I found your website and read your pieces about sleeping and eating. I carefully read through your schedules and decided to try it.

IT WORKED!! 

And within a week or two our little girl changed from a frustrated baby into this happy dappy smiling ray of sunshine, that is able to settle herself down by sucking on her fists, even in the middle of the night. At 12 weeks baby girl slept through the night and now at 20 weeks old she sleeps a good 10 to 12 hours every night. 

I just wanted to thank you for sharing your experience online. The way you wrote your experiences made it understandable, seeing it from the babys side but also the moms side. Maybe we were lucky that your way fitted our baby, but it worked and I tell it to everyone that wants to know!

Stephanie P.

“Had tremendous success from Day One!”

I just wanted to thank you for your sample routine.  I’ve been using it for a week with my 13 month old and had tremendous success from day 2! Wind down time is so important and so is consistency.  Thank you so much!!!

Sam M.

“In a few short days…”

I am grateful to have found your blog, as I do a great deal of searching on Pinterest when I am up against a parenting moment that I do not feel qualified to handle.

I will say though that since reading your blog I am really focusing on remembering that every moment is a learning \ experience for my son and I try to take a breath and count to ten. In the few short days that I have been exercising this method I truly have noticed a change for the better in his response to me.

Tami K.

Comments

  1. Audrey says

    I love this. It isn’t about being good – that leads us to think we don’t need Jesus because we are good enough on our own. Instead, I want to focus on the specific action to praise, as you’ve suggested.

    Reply
    • Rachel Norman says

      Exactly Audrey. Being “good” in that sense is impossible. And such a great point that we must point to Jesus as the one who makes us righteous through Him.

      Reply
  2. Kerri says

    I’m having difficulty getting my 3 almost 4 year old daughter to go to the potty at night. I used to put a pull up on her at night but felt like to was kinda being lazy when she had one on instead of getting up and going. Anyways she still has accidents at night and when she doesn’t I find myself praising her for it. I’m not sure this is appropriate since maybe it’s not in her full control? Any advice is appreciated–thank you!

    Reply
    • Rachel Norman says

      Kerri, I still think it’s great to praise her for doing it. As long as you aren’t insulting her when she doesn’t. You know? It’s okay for her to feel proud she’s getting there!

      Reply
  3. anastasia says

    Dear Rachel,

    we live in London and today was my daughter’s first day at the nursery ( she is 2) and I hated. I am so emotionally a rack . They are not establishing healthy emotional relationship at all, they trying to put the children into a box. They praise them with a good girl and good boy whenever they do something good according to them, and so on.
    What is your opinion about that. Is there any alternatives?

    Reply
    • Rachel Norman says

      It’s so hard when it’s another establishment because you can’t really control them. Perhaps you could suggest an alterate phrase?

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hey y'all, I'm Rachel Norman, BA, MS, Language of Listening® parenting coach, mother to 5 babies in 5 years on 3 continents, no multiples. Join me in parenting without losing your mind. Read More >>

Search

Copyright © 2021 All Rights Reserved | A Mother Far From Home | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Accessibility














15 Minute Projects To Get Your Home In Order

In just 15 minutes a night (while you're in your pj's!) take your home from stressed out to organized with these 101+ 15 minute projects. 


envelope
envelope
close
x